Brussels Has Chosen a Negotiator Who Does Not Want to Negotiate

Handing the EU’s Russia file to Kallas, whose stated aim is to break Russia into smaller states, is not diplomacy. Because she is in charge, Moscow may rightly treat that aim as official EU policy and refuse to meet her. Italy should refuse to be dragged further into a war that is not its own.


If you wanted to design an appointment that guarantees no negotiation will ever take place, you could hardly do better than what is now being prepared in Brussels: handing the EU’s Russia file to Kallas, a politician whose stated ambition is to break Russia into smaller states.

This is not a detail. It compresses the entire method of European foreign policy into one name. A negotiator accepts that the other side exists, has interests, and will still be there when the talking is over. Someone who wants to dismantle the country across the table is not a mediator. They are a belligerent with a chair and a nameplate.

And because Kallas is in charge of the file, her stated aim cannot be waved away as a personal opinion. What she says is, in effect, EU official policy. President Putin may therefore perceive—rightly—that the European Union has adopted as formal policy the break-up of Russia. If that is the EU’s position, Russia would see Brussels as an impediment to any peace process. Moscow should refuse to meet her, and it would be right to do so.

It is also worth asking what is supposed to be negotiated. Russia has done nothing to us. The European Union inserted itself into a war that does not belong to it, then cut every diplomatic channel with Moscow, and made negotiation impossible by its own hand. A Union of Peace would have spent these years as mediator. Ours spent them as a participant, and now looks for someone to conduct the talks it destroyed the conditions for.

And this is no accident of personnel. It is the culmination of a strategy that has failed on its own terms, publicly, for years. I have said for five years that sanctions against Russia were an epic failure, and I take some satisfaction that the message has travelled as far as Moscow. Twenty-one packages, the latest adopted in July 2026, each presented as the one that would finally bite, each producing the same result. Brussels responds with another package, on the road of failure, because that is the modus operandi—getting everything wrong and calling it principle.

So when I look at the choice of chief negotiator, I do not see incompetence alone. I see a coherent position: the goal is not a settlement, it is the transformation, or the break-up, of the other country. That is a regime-change policy, and regime-change policies do not end in treaties. They end in exhaustion, in resentment, and in the decline of the powers that adopt them. It is due to people like this that empires fall.

Why does such a line survive every piece of contrary evidence? My friend Desmet, in his book, has an answer that fits our political class: people have lost the capacity to analyse and take positions mainly out of the need to feel accepted by their friends and acquaintances—often against their own interest. He calls it mass totalitarianism. I recognise it; I did a version of it myself as a teenager. Today it is the operating system of an entire foreign policy, and anyone who points at the results is treated as an accomplice rather than a critic.

And the true enemy of European peoples is not Russia. It is the ignorance, incompetence and arrogance of most of our leaders, in Brussels and member states—ignorance and arrogance being the same thing. Those leaders are not defending our values. Paradoxically, it will not be this Commission that preserves them.

Which brings us to Italy. We have no quarrel with Russia, and no interest in a crusade dressed as morality: twelve packages of Italian arms have gone to Kyiv since 2022. When a minister admits that Italians are against continuing to finance and arm that war—61 per cent, in a Eumetra poll conducted in September 2026—and then says he will go on anyway, we are no longer in a democracy, but in a democracy with Italian characteristics: I am the king, and you can get lost.

So Italy should say no, clearly and in public. No to a negotiator whose programme is dismantling the country she is meant to negotiate with. No to further sanctions packages whose only measurable effect is on our own firms and households. No to the pretence that Ukraine is fighting for our democracy, when what is defended is the Brussels bureaucracy’s idea of itself.

We should demand a mandate for settlement rather than transformation, restoration of diplomatic channels, and bilateral dealings wherever our national interest is at stake—treating Brussels as a liability to be minimised, not a compass. This is not neutrality between good and evil. It is the minimum a sovereign country owes its citizens: not to be dragged into someone else’s war, under someone else’s flag, for someone else’s reasons.

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *